“The chickens have come home to roost.” Asmongold’s embittered response to the American midterm elections seems to prove true the old adage: even a broken clock can be right once a day–and you would be hard pressed to find a clock more broken than Asmongold. Honestly, on the rare occasions that I can stomach more than 30 seconds of his amateurish proto-fascist slop, I don’t know whether to point and laugh at his semi-sentient incoherence, or pray for the power to reach through my screen in order to wrap a warm blanket around the chap’s emaciated shoulders.
Of course, the streamer Asmongold, like a great number of the moral invalids that dominate the online commentariat of the MAGA movement, did not miss the opportunity to stumble on precisely the wrong interpretation of the Republican party’s electoral curb-stomping, claiming that Trump’s regime lost because “Trump didn’t do fifty different fucking things that he should have done. I think that he should have gone a thousand fucking times harder.” Or, to put it another way, Trump’s regime was punished by the electorate for being too moderate. This belief was conveyed somewhat more eloquently by Steve Bannon, the former White House strategist for Donald Trump, a former media executive at Breitbart News, and current political podcaster (because of course he is). Bannon, during an interview with Emily Maitlis, asserted that Trump should have done more with ICE, arguing that “MAGA sees the lack of implementation of policies that were supposed to sort this out. He was very clear in 2024, everybody understood it was gonna be mass deportations.”
This is a sentiment that has also been echoed on this side of the pond by some British far-right commentators. Carl Benjamin, in a video he posted reflecting on the midterm results stated that this election “was Trump’s to lose,” claiming that “all he [Trump] had to do was follow his campaign promises.” Benjamin later went on to claim that “the British right is slightly ahead of the American right[…]Americans are still struggling to make the Republican party the thing it needs to be. In Britain we have that option already…”
Benjamin is a supporter of Rupert Lowe’s Restore Britain party, an organisation that is currently locked in a curious power-squabble against Nigel Farage and the Reform UK Party Limited over the scraps of Britain’s radical right-wing voting base. Rupert Lowe rarely misses any opportunity to spout his most popular catchphrase: “millions must go,” and on the 2nd September 2026, Restore Britain published a statement titled: “Restore Britain’s Philosophy Of National Belonging.”
In this document, Lowe criticised the “demographic vandalism inflicted on us by successive governments,” before elaborating on Restore’s policies regarding mass migration, stating: “We will end immigration entirely from the Third World, discriminate based on the rolling evidence through our forthcoming red list policy, and remove millions of foreign nationals who should not be in our country – both legal and illegal[…The objective is straightforward. Millions of foreign nationals leaving the country.” For anyone who might be about to express alarm about who exactly would qualify to become one of the millions of foreign nationals that will receive a one-way ticket out of this formerly United Kingdom, Lowe very helpfully makes it clear that this will include: “Those legal migrants who refuse to accept our culture, our way of life, our identity.” It is clear that Benjamin and his allies in the British far-right would prefer to see the American Republican party embrace similar policies to Restore Britain. On the 4th of November, he retweeted a statement made by the conservative political commentator, Matt Walsh, which declared that: “The MAGA political movement is dead but America First as a movement and principle lives on and must live on. If the Republican Party will have any future, it will be through America First.” (We will return to this idea of “America First” in a moment).
Matt Walsh is yet another member of the right-wing chattering classes who has urged for a more hardline stance on immigration. Responding on X to a 60 Minutes interview featuring President Trump, Walsh argued that the Trump administration’s deportation policy was not “too tough” and that “there need to be more deportations, not fewer.” It is a curious phenomena that so many MAGA and MAGA-adjacent political commentators have now so radically outpaced their former orange idol on the issue of deportations. In their world, the Overton window isn’t just shifting, it’s cartwheeling further and further right…
It wasn’t just new media talking heads who seemed determined to deny any suggestion that the Republican party’s rapid veering to the right might have left behind large swathes of the American public. Sean Hannity, a veteran Fox News political commentator, also weighed in. After wasting several minutes fearmongering over the newly elected Democrats being “the most radical in the history of our country,” Hannity went on to defend Trump’s military intervention in Iran, whilst urging Republicans that “if you believe in tax cuts, limited government, greater freedom, stay the course…” I suppose it shouldn’t be that much of a surprise to see a Fox News propagandist espousing a vapid defence of tax cuts; at this point, it’s about as shocking as seeing a fly on a turd, or a rich person in the Epstein files. The more naive amongst you might ask yourselves how a fellow like Hannity can sleep at night, playing defence for a philosophy of deregulation and limited government that strips working class Americans of their health care coverage and guts food assistance for children and veterans. The answer is obvious; he sleeps very soundly, on a very comfortable bed.
Though, for now, Hannity might just be alone in this. A strange panic is gripping the Republican party, and I don’t doubt that for the next two years a great number of Trump’s former cheerleaders are going to be haunted by night-terrors involving blue donkeys and dead Iranian schoolgirls. The man who was once able to weave around his many, many detractors like a graceless ballerina now seems to have put his fat right foot on a discarded rake, walloping himself in the face like a less dignified Sideshow Bob. Trump, who not so long ago was considered the Republican’s mighty orange right hook, now appears to be an albatross dangling around the party’s limp neck. It’s a staggering downgrade from the unstoppable wrecking ball that so thoroughly demolished the campaigns of Kamala Harris and Joe Biden; though I doubt if poor old Joe can remember this very clearly. I suspect that for Barack Obama’s former right-hand man, the vast bulk of 2024 is nothing more than a disturbing and confusing tangerine haze.
Whilst a sizeable contingent of MAGA’s supporters in the media clearly want the party to double and triple down on their hardline policies regarding immigration and deregulation, there is another faction emerging from from the more disgruntled flying monkeys who have read the writing on the wall and are starting to worry that they are about to be deprived of quite a few bananas in the immediate future. By all accounts, the mood in the White House appears to have taken on the rather pitiful atmosphere of a funeral wake, with a great number of Republicans grieving their fallen party.
Some managed to relocate their previously discarded spines and dared even to criticise the party’s Supreme Leader. John Curtis, the Senator for Utah, reflected sombrely on the midterm results, saying “After the Biden era, Americans wanted an economy that worked for them. Instead, they received a hastily executed war, headline after headline of scandals, a ballooning $40tn dollar debt, and unpredictable tariffs[…]It’s time for Republicans to return to the principled conservative values that once defined us – and that we’ve steadily abandoned.” Bill Miller, a top Republican lobbyist in the now-blue Texas, told the BBC that the result was “a total, complete rejection of President Trump.” Mike Pence took the opportunity to flee to his X platform and opine about the urgent need for the Republican party to return “to the timeless principles that have led to our greatest successes…” Pence also described the midterm election as a “reckoning,” saying that “The American people have rejected our party’s shift towards economic populism.”
A more charitable critic might be inclined to say “better late than never,” but there are no more charitable critics to be found, not in this blighted century. Personally, I would have preferred it if the Republican establishment had found a spare moment over the past two years to pull themselves away from Donald’s rancid bottom to offer even a performative bleat in protest over the Iranian disaster, but I suppose that would have been asking too much of them. All this talk about a return to some mythical past where the Republican party was guided by “timeless principles” is especially headscratching. Frankly, I wasn’t aware that the Republicans had any principles to abandon in the first place.
Still, all of this disgruntled murmuring doesn’t bode well for the President. How he will take it is quite frankly anyone’s guess. As funny as it is to imagine a lame duck Donald Trump, I can’t help but cling to my pessimism. Any lifeguard worth their salt will tell you that a drowning man is often extremely dangerous and must be approached with great caution. If he manages to get a firm grip on his saviour he will not hesitate, in his blind and frenzied panic, to drag them into the black and icy depths. Trump’s grip on the country might have been weakened, but even a small child can dish out quite a lot of damage as they flail their arms in a savage tantrum–if you don’t believe me, talk to any teaching assistant at a primary or junior school and they will show you their battle scars. The Democrats should not allow themselves to be lulled into a false sense of security. It is not hard to imagine Trump dragging large chunks of the country down into the black and icy depths with him as he struggles ferociously to escape his encroaching political irrelevance. There was a pre-Trump era to politics and so, inevitably, one day, we will arrive at a post-Trump era…how much blood will be spilled as we shamble past that threshold depends very much on the humility of the American President and the intelligence of his opposition. Again, you can see why I am still clinging to my pessimism…
The question does need to be raised, however, why exactly did Trump’s pawns take such a battering? After all, as recently as 2024, Trump won the popular vote in what was trumpeted by his communications director, Steven Cheung, as a “landslide victory.” So what changed? Why, oh why have the American people soured so swiftly on poor Donald? Well, let us return to Matt Walsh’s comments about America First. Now, is there really anyone on God’s formerly green earth who believes that there has ever been a point in history when America did not put itself first? In 2014, The New York Times reported a study by the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) that reviewed major terrorist operations that were run by the White House. The purpose of this report was to determine the factors that led to the failure or success of these operations. In this article, Trump’s predecessor, Barack Obama, was quoted as saying that he had asked the CIA to carry out this inquiry in order to explore how many cases of “financing and supplying arms to an insurgency in a country” had actually “worked out well.” The former president is quoted as saying “they [the CIA] couldn’t come up with much.”
America has always been a beast motivated by self-interest. Which, to be fair, does not make it all that different to any other global power in human history. No, what marks the Americans out is their sheer incompetence and staggering inability to learn from past blunders. Anyway, the point I’m driving at is there is no risk of America not putting itself first. Certainly not in geopolitical terms. So, this response from Walsh doesn’t appear to hold much water. It would be more accurate to say that what really seems to have angered the electorate is their government’s inability to put Americans first. Especially the Americans that make up the lower-middle and working classes.
Why did Trump’s forces suffer so badly during the midterms? Well, to borrow a phrase from James Carville: It’s the economy, stupid! From coast to coast, countless Americans are being forced to grapple with the rising cost of essentials. A higher-than-anticipated rate of inflation, coupled with two years of significant job cuts that have been at least partially bolstered by the rapid incorporation of artificial intelligence in the workforce–something that has been heavily championed by President Trump. Under Trump’s reign, there has also been a major spike in financial insecurity and households reporting that they do not have enough to eat. So, to put it simply, considerable swathes of the American electorate are, right now, financially insecure, increasingly hungry, and increasingly frustrated by the increased costs of day-to-day necessities. “Everything’s going up,” as one North Carolina voter told the BBC prior to the midterms.
Then, of course, there was the shambolic affair of the Iran war. Honestly, when will western leaders learn to stop poking their noses into that particular geopolitical beehive? It really never does end well. The less said about that whole idiotic fiasco, the better. Far more intelligent commentators than me have weighed in on this. My criticisms over the incompetent regime-fiddling of the Americans has nothing to do with sympathy for the Iranian regime, by the way (I’m talking to you, Sarah Vine). Nor am I inherently opposed to military action. One doesn’t have to be a bleeding heart diet progressive, or a simpering pacifist/masochist to see that this whole bloody tragicomedy could have been so easily avoided if the world had some proper statesmen (or women, Sarah Vine) at the wheel. All I will say is that it’s very hard to posture as the “no new wars” president when you’re lobbing bombs at Iranian schoolchildren. This is just the warped philosophy of “peace through strength” in action, only wielded by a moron with a dictator-complex. The problem with the whole mantra of peace through strength is that peace never actually arrives, and the more corpses litter the ground before your podium, the weaker you end up looking on the international (let alone domestic) stage. Again, you don’t have to be some woke-addled snowflake to believe that this may have seriously impacted the Republicans. Many far-right commentators, including Carl Benjamin and his colleagues at the Lotus Eaters, have stated that the Iranian conflict likely cost Trump a lot of support from his base.
The economy and Iran would probably be good enough reasons for the so-called Blue Wave that swept through the American electorate this November. I wonder, however, if there may be another reason, buried under all the foreign-policy bumbling and economic anxiety. Perhaps we are witnessing the beginning of Trump-fatigue. Think about it. It’s now been over a decade since the intellectually stunted satsuma stampeded his way onto the international stage. For a while, a lot of us were content to just laugh at the strange, three-dimensional cartoon…but the laughter, I’m afraid, just seems to be wearing a bit thin, these days. Perhaps, finally, Americans are starting to get a bit fed up with their tangerine tyrant. Donald Trump is essentially a sitcom President, a strange and charmless hybrid of Archie Bunker and Barnie Stinson, and there is nothing more irritating than a sitcom that limps on and on, enduring years beyond the point where it should have been cancelled. Perhaps giving the Democrats their moment in the sun is the best way that the American public can make it clear to poor, old Donald Trump: we’re just not that into you. Not anymore.







